For boys who like boys who like joysticks!


« Review: Inception | Main | What Do You Want To Know About The 3DS? »

In Defense Of Video Games

Every gamer has memories of the few games that stick out, those that caused you to feel or experience something that truly moved you. notart1.jpgFor me, they served as potent evidence that video games could serve not merely as cheap entertainment, or as a way to pass the time in the often-uneventful days of youth, but as a genuine art form. There will always be those who roll their eyes in casual derision at the thought of games as "art." Digital Lit recently posted an article highlighting Ebert's latest snipe in his ongoing jihad against video games, but i'll largely skip over that for now, since the article gives a very succinct rebuttal. More after the jump!

It may be a vaguely sympathetic argument -- one might even be tempted to at least believe that they have noble intentions -- that video games have unduly encroached into the world of film, television and literature; but the tired, old-hat tendency to shrug off gaming as nothing more than a childish pursuit simply reeks of "Get off my lawn!" New mediums of creativity will always have their naysayers. The rise of movies no doubt elicited wailings from the older generations about the death of plays and literature; the creation of television certainly must have come up against those who decried it as nothing more than quick, cheap, easy-to-swallow perversions of film. But defying the scoffs of the dinosaurs of yesteryear, those modes of expression have provided us with a rich and wonderful history, as well as stories that have captured our hearts and imaginations. Surely there have been some truly atrocious and Philistine games (*cough* Postal 2 *cough*), but they no more reflect gaming as a whole than the latest cookie-cutter action flick reflects cinema. Contrary to the notion that video games elevate the cretinous, thus dumbing-down our sense of the elements so crucial to art, i find that games have only helped me to develop an appreciation for such things. As video games have evolved from the bloops and blips that spawned them, so has their sophistication. Over the years I've learned to recognize the grace of the aesthetics, the arcs and twists of the story, the development of the characters, the feel of the music, and the subtle interplay of all these elements to create one coherent, artistic work.

But unlike a film, in which the screen serves as a voyeuristic experience of the story, the interactivity present in video games provides a framework in which certain stories can only be truly realized. This was most powerfully evident to me the first time i played Shadow of the Colossus. As the game wore on and i watched Wander's humanity slowly fading -- becoming more and more emaciated with each passing battle -- it dawned on me that i was not simply sitting there, helplessly watch his slow demise. He was killing himself, and i was helping him do it. My heart sunk, and the chill that ran through me was much different than anything a movie could produce. That's not to say that video games are necessarily better -- that they are superior to films in any respect -- but in the case of the aforementioned memory, the distinctive emotional impact was so dependent on the interaction with the protagonist as to diminish it on any other medium.

In the world of art, there's room for one more genre. It will never eclipse film (nor should it), but that doesn't relegate it to an inferior status. For every person that says that there will never be a video game as good as a film, there is another behind them crying that there will never be a film as good as a book. Rather than pigeonholing art by trying to fit it neatly into a little box, as stubborn grumps like Ebert insist on doing, i suggest that we look at the concept in a broader sense and acknowledge that art is, at its core, the end result of purposeful and expressive creativity.


Andrew said:

Its partly fallacious to talk about video games as an interactive medium as understood in the greater context of cultural theory, and this article is excellent reading on the topic:

not that your argument is invalid at all, and the voices of people like Ebert are gradually being drowned out by the growing appreciation in the academic world for video games as a valid topic for discourse on art and culture.

Rosa said:

Ebert is wrong about this, but I'm tired of people whining about him. He's wrong, but he's old. And he doesn't get it. And he's an amazingly intelligent man in all other areas, and we look like militant children getting as upset about this as we do.

gaymer_geek said:

Ebert's latest snipe is hardly new, he's just rementioning something he said last summer about his Huck Finn versus Video Games Poll.

Not to play the devil's advocate, but alot of gamers are making a mountain out a mole hill, and something thats taken slightly out of context.

Ebert has his opinion, he's hardly declared war against video games, just stated an opinion, and he's not even pressuring it on anyone, just blogging about it.

His goals seem honourable as he's really just trying to build up lots of rhetoric around his argument of how important Mark Twain's works are (especially when they are read by young people).

As I mentioned in the other article you can't hold the man responsible for something he isn't really aiming for, his apparent hatred of the vidja' games. He's even gone on to say he went a bit to far to even bring the comparision up.

Mountain out of a mole hill, and that is me as a gamer talking. It's not as if he's targeting gamers or demonizing us, he just said something that doesn't jive with how we view things. Leave the man be, all alone without video games !

And girls who like girls who like rumble packs!

Twitter Feed

Recent Comments

gaymer_geek on In Defense Of Video Games: Ebert's latest snipe is hardly new, he's just rementioning something he said last summer about his Huck Finn versus Video...

Rosa on In Defense Of Video Games: Ebert is wrong about this, but I'm tired of people whining about him. He's wrong, but he's old. And he...

Andrew on In Defense Of Video Games: Its partly fallacious to talk about video games as an interactive medium as understood in the greater context of cultural...

GGP Mailing List

Are you gay and working in the games industry? If you are interested in networking with other folks like you within the industry, try joining the Gay Game-Industry Professionals mailing list. Click here for all the details!


The GayGamer Store

  • Help support GayGamer by purchasing your items through our store!

All rights reserved © 2006-2010 FAD Media, Inc.